Articles

 

(from the Shelton-Mason County Chamber of Commerce Business Matters magazine, December 2025)

​

Compliance with Federal payroll tax rules is an essential component of running a successful business. However, these rules are often misunderstood, leading to errors and IRS Notices. The amount of detail required to comply with these rules is significant, considering the complexities surrounding withholding obligations, worker classification issues, fringe benefit reporting, and filing deadlines. Thankfully, a solid grasp of the basic mechanics of payroll tax can provide a healthy foundation for business owners to achieve compliance and reduce the risk of penalties.

 

Below is a summary of the key requirements that employers must meet in this area.

 

Payroll Tax Overview

 

Federal payroll taxes are imposed on wages earned by employees that perform services for an employer. Federal income tax (FIT) is an estimated prepayment of each employee’s individual income tax liability, and is calculated using inputs from Form W-4, Employee’s Withholding Certificate. Social Security tax and regular Medicare tax are collectively called FICA taxes and require the employer and employee to contribute equal amounts. The employee-only Additional Medicare Tax applies to certain high earners. Lastly, employers must pay Federal unemployment tax (FUTA) on wages paid to employees. Different wage thresholds apply to each payroll tax. Employers are expected to calculate and withhold the correct amounts of FIT and FICA from employee wages.

 

Deposit Requirements

 

Employers must deposit Federal payroll taxes with the IRS. Deposits of FIT and FICA must be made either monthly or semiweekly, depending on the employer’s cumulative employment tax liability during a four-quarter lookback period. Monthly deposits are due on the 15th of each month for taxes attributable to wages paid in the previous month. Semiweekly deposits are due either Wednesday or Friday, depending on the day wages were paid. Deposits of FUTA are due the last day of the month following each quarter where the cumulative FUTA tax is more than $500. Employers can use the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System (EFTPS) to make these deposits.

 

Employee Versus Independent Contractor

 

When hiring workers, it is critical for businesses to make the correct determination regarding worker classification. Employees receive wages which are reported on Form W-2 and subject to the aforementioned payroll taxes. Independent contractors receive payments, which are reported on Forms 1099 and are generally exempt from payroll taxes at the business level. Note there are certain situations where backup withholding may apply.

 

The IRS criteria for determining worker status is based on facts grouped into three categories: behavioral control, financial control, and the relationship of the parties. Employers should carefully review and understand this criteria, and treat workers that perform the same duties consistently for payroll reporting purposes. Misclassification of a worker can lead to retroactive assessment of payroll taxes, penalties, and interest by the IRS. While corrective procedures exist if misclassification occurs, it is undoubtedly preferable to report wages and payments correctly from the outset.

 

Fringe Benefits

 

Fringe benefits are non-cash compensation items provided to employees. There are a wide variety of fringe benefits offered by employers to attract and retain talent, and these are often particular to a given industry or company size. Fringe benefits are considered taxable income to employees unless specifically excluded under IRS rules. Certain benefits may be subject to some payroll taxes, but not others. Further, generally excludible benefits may be pulled back into taxable income for 2%-or-greater S Corp shareholders, key employees, or highly compensated employees. Common fringe benefits include health insurance premiums, retirement plan contributions, group term life insurance coverage, commuter or parking benefits, gift cards, and tickets to sporting events.

 

Reporting Obligations

 

Employers must file Form 941, Employer’s Quarterly Federal Tax Return, with the IRS by the last day of the month following each quarter. Form 940, Employer's Annual Federal Unemployment (FUTA) Tax Return, is due on January 31. Forms W-2, Wage and Tax Statement, must be issued to employees and submitted to the Social Security Administration (SSA) by January 31. Employers should also file Form W-3, Transmittal of Wage and Tax Statements, with the SSA by January 31. When preparing for year-end, payroll professionals should confirm that the amounts on Form W-3 tie to the totals of the quarterly Forms 941.

 

Final Thoughts

​

A strategic approach to payroll tax compliance demands more than relying on software. It requires employers to consider their withholding, depositing, and reporting obligations, understand worker classification rules, and evaluate the taxation of fringe benefits. These tasks must be performed while staying aware of changes in tax law and timely responding to communications from tax authorities. To achieve this, businesses should adopt a proactive mindset, create and document standardized processes, and consult with a professional advisor when needed.​

​

​